Social Media Platforms

Global Marketing, Advertising Strategies & Models: DAGMAR and Hierarchy of Effects

 Global Marketing

Global marketing can be defined as “marketing on a worldwide scale by reconciling or taking commercial advantage of global operational differences, similarities, and opportunities in order to achieve global objectives.”

Global marketing is not a revolutionary shift; rather, it is an evolutionary process. Although the stages described below may not apply to every company, they generally represent the progression followed by many companies that initially operate only in their domestic markets.


    1. Domestic Marketing

    Domestic marketing refers to marketing activities that are restricted to the political boundaries of a particular country.

    A company engaged only in domestic marketing primarily focuses on competition within its home market. Even when some of its competitors are foreign companies, the company generally considers only those competitors operating in its domestic market.

    The major challenge faced by domestic marketers is the possibility of being blindsided by emerging global competitors. Since they generally do not pay close attention to developments in the global marketplace, they may fail to recognize a potential competitor that is already a market leader across several continents.

    Domestic marketers can be described as ethnocentric, as they are primarily concerned with their company's performance and reputation within their home country.

    2. International Marketing

    International marketing begins when a company's export operations become successful, but conducting business from its headquarters creates challenges such as high operating costs, time-zone differences, language barriers, and limited understanding of foreign cultures. These factors may reduce the company's competitiveness in international markets.

    To overcome these challenges, a company may establish offices or subsidiaries in foreign countries. In some cases, companies may acquire existing firms in foreign markets to benefit from their established business relationships, retail outlets, factories, distribution networks, and personnel.

    Although these foreign offices continue to report to the headquarters in the home country, many marketing-mix decisions are made locally, because employees in each country have a better understanding of the needs, preferences, and characteristics of their target market.

    International marketers are therefore considered polycentric, because they recognize that different countries and markets have different needs and require different marketing strategies.

     

     

    Elements of the Global Marketing Mix

    The “Four Ps” of marketing—Product, Price, Place, and Promotion— are all affected as a company progresses through the various evolutionary stages of becoming a global organization.

    At the global marketing level, a company that aims to communicate with one consistent voice across different markets faces several challenges when developing a worldwide marketing plan. These challenges become more complex when the company does not hold the same competitive position in every market—for example, being a market leader in one country but a low-cost competitor or a challenger in another.

    1. Product

    A global company aims to create a standardized product that can be marketed across different countries while making necessary modifications to suit local market requirements.

    For example, Coca-Cola uses different formulations in some markets, including versions made with sugar and others made with corn syrup. Its packaging also varies from country to country. The contour bottle design may include the local language, while the size and packaging formats are adapted to match the beverage containers commonly used in each market.

    Thus, global companies attempt to achieve a balance between product standardization and local adaptation.

    2. Price

    Price varies from one market to another and is influenced by numerous factors. These include the cost of product development, whether the product is manufactured locally or imported, the cost of ingredients or raw materials, transportation expenses, tariffs, taxes, distribution costs, and other market-specific factors.

    The company's competitive positioning also influences pricing. Whether the product is positioned as a premium or high-end offering, an economical low-cost option, or a product in between helps determine the appropriate price point for each market.

    Therefore, global companies must develop pricing strategies that take into account both global objectives and local market conditions.

    3. Place (Placement)

    Place refers to how and where a product is distributed and made available to customers. Distribution decisions are generally influenced by the characteristics of each country's market, consumer habits, infrastructure, and competitive environment.

    Using Coca-Cola as an example, not every culture or market relies on vending machines to the same extent. Similarly, beverage distribution methods differ across countries. In the United States, beverages may be sold in large quantities through warehouse-style retail stores, whereas such a distribution approach may not be equally suitable in India.

    Therefore, placement decisions must be adapted to local market conditions while also considering the product's competitive position and target customers.

    4. Promotion

    After product research, development, and creation, promotion is often one of the largest components of a global company's marketing budget.

    A global corporation generally aims to reduce costs, minimize duplication of work and personnel, accelerate implementation, and maintain a consistent global brand message.

    However, communicating the same core message across different countries presents a significant challenge. Cultural differences, languages, consumer preferences, media habits, and local market conditions can affect how a message is received.

    Therefore, the key challenge for a global company is to communicate a consistent brand message in a relevant, engaging, culturally appropriate, and cost-effective manner.

    Quick Summary of Global Marketing Mix

    The global marketing mix requires companies to balance standardization and adaptation. While maintaining a consistent global brand identity can create efficiency and strengthen the brand, adapting products, prices, distribution, and promotional strategies to local market conditions is essential for achieving success in diverse international markets.

    Advantages of Global Marketing and Advertising

    Global marketing and advertising provide several important benefits to organizations operating across international markets. By coordinating marketing activities on a global scale, companies can reduce costs, strengthen their brand image, improve efficiency, and take advantage of opportunities across different markets.

    1. Lower Marketing Costs

    Global marketing can help companies reduce marketing costs by developing common strategies, advertising campaigns, promotional materials, and communication programs that can be adapted and used across multiple countries.

    2. Greater Power and Scope

    Operating in international markets gives a company greater market power and broader reach. A global presence can strengthen the company's competitive position, increase its customer base, and provide access to a wider range of markets and resources.

    3. Consistency in Brand Image

    Global marketing helps maintain a consistent brand image across different countries. Using similar brand elements, messages, logos, and communication strategies enables customers worldwide to recognize and associate the brand with the same values and identity.

    4. Uniformity of Marketing Practices

    Global marketing encourages a greater degree of uniformity in marketing practices. Common approaches to advertising, branding, product positioning, and promotional activities can improve coordination and make it easier for companies to manage their international operations.

    5. Benefits of eMarketing over Traditional Marketing

    eMarketing provides several advantages over traditional marketing, particularly for companies operating globally. Digital platforms allow businesses to reach customers across different countries quickly and at relatively lower costs. Companies can also target specific customer segments, measure campaign performance, interact directly with consumers, and modify campaigns in real time.

    6. Economies of Scale in Production and Distribution

    Global operations enable companies to achieve economies of scale by producing and distributing products in larger quantities. Higher production volumes can reduce the average cost per unit, while coordinated distribution systems can lower transportation, storage, and other operating costs.

     

    7. Ability to Leverage Good Ideas Quickly and Efficiently

    Global companies can identify successful ideas in one market and quickly adapt or implement them in other markets. This allows organizations to share knowledge, successful advertising campaigns, innovative products, and effective marketing practices across their international operations.

    Quick Summary of Advantages of Global Marketing and Advertising

    Global marketing and advertising help companies achieve cost efficiency, wider market reach, stronger brand consistency, standardized practices, economies of scale, and faster transfer of successful ideas. However, companies must balance global consistency with appropriate adaptation to local market conditions.

    Disadvantages of Global Marketing and Advertising

    Although global marketing and advertising provide several advantages, companies operating in international markets also face a number of challenges. Differences in markets, cultures, regulations, consumer behavior, and competitive conditions can make it difficult to apply a single marketing strategy worldwide.

    1. Differences in Administrative Procedures

    Administrative procedures, regulations, legal requirements, taxation systems, and business practices vary from country to country. These differences can make it difficult for companies to standardize their marketing and advertising activities across international markets.

    2. Differences in Product Placement

    The methods and channels used to distribute and present products may differ significantly across countries. Differences in retail structures, distribution networks, infrastructure, consumer shopping habits, and market conditions can require companies to adopt different product-placement strategies.

    3. Differences in Consumer Response to Marketing Mix Elements

    Consumers in different countries may respond differently to product, price, place, and promotion. An advertising campaign or promotional strategy that is successful in one market may not produce the same results in another because of differences in culture, values, preferences, and purchasing behavior.

    4. Differences in Consumer Needs, Wants, and Usage Patterns

    Consumer needs, wants, preferences, and product-usage patterns vary across countries. Factors such as culture, income levels, climate, lifestyle, traditions, and social values influence consumer behavior. Therefore, a standardized product or marketing strategy may not satisfy customers equally in every market.

    5. Differences in Administrative Procedures and Product Placement

    The combination of different administrative requirements and distribution practices can create additional challenges for global companies. Organizations may need to modify their operating procedures, distribution systems, and marketing activities to comply with local requirements and effectively reach consumers.

    6. Differences in Brand and Product Development

    The process of brand building and product development may differ across international markets. Products that are successful in one country may require modification in another to meet local consumer expectations, cultural preferences, regulations, or market conditions.

    7. Differences in the Competitive Environment

    The competitive environment varies from country to country. A company may be a market leader in one country but face strong competition from established local or international brands in another. Differences in competitors, market share, pricing strategies, and competitive intensity can therefore make it difficult to follow a uniform global marketing strategy.

    Quick Summary of Disadvantages of Global Marketing and Advertising

    Global marketing and advertising can be challenging because markets are not identical. Differences in administrative procedures, distribution systems, consumer behavior, product requirements, brand development, and competitive environments often require companies to balance global standardization with local adaptation.

    DAGMAR Approach

    The DAGMAR advertising model was proposed by Russell H. Colley in 1961. DAGMAR is an acronym for Defining Advertising Goals for Measured Advertising Results.

    Colley identified 52 advertising goals that could be applied to a single advertisement, an annual advertising campaign for a product, or the overall advertising philosophy of a company.

    DAGMAR is essentially an approach to advertising planning that provides a precise method for defining, selecting, and quantifying advertising objectives and using those objectives to measure advertising performance.

    The approach places particular emphasis on measurement and clearly defined objectives. It encourages advertisers to establish objectives that are specific, operational, and measurable so that the effectiveness of an advertising campaign can be evaluated objectively.

    The Four Steps of DAGMAR

    According to the DAGMAR approach, a potential customer generally passes through four stages before making a purchase:

    1. Awareness

    The first step is to create awareness. The consumer must become aware of the existence of the brand, product, or company.

    2. Comprehension

    Once awareness has been created, the consumer must develop an understanding of the product, including what it is, what it offers, and what benefits it provides.

    3. Conviction

    At this stage, the consumer develops a positive mental attitude or conviction toward the brand. The consumer becomes persuaded that the product can satisfy a particular need and develops an intention to purchase it.

    4. Action

    The final stage is action, in which the consumer actually takes the desired action, such as purchasing the product.

    ACCA Formula

    The four stages of DAGMAR are also known as the ACCA advertising formula:

    A → Awareness → C → Comprehension → C → Conviction → A → Action

    DAGMAR is considered a descendant of the AIDA advertising model and is often regarded as more comprehensive because it places greater emphasis on specific objectives and the measurement of advertising effectiveness.

    Importance of DAGMAR

    The DAGMAR approach:

    • Helps advertisers define clear and measurable advertising objectives.
    • Provides a framework for measuring advertising effectiveness.
    • Maps the states of mind through which a consumer passes before taking action.
    • Helps evaluate whether an advertising campaign has achieved its intended communication objectives.
    • Makes advertising planning more systematic, objective, and measurable.

     

    Characteristics or Objectives of the DAGMAR Approach

    The DAGMAR approach emphasizes the development of clear, specific, and measurable advertising objectives. The major characteristics of effective DAGMAR objectives are as follows:

    1. Concrete and Measurable

    The communication task or objective should be a precise statement of what the advertiser wants to communicate to the target audience. The objective should clearly specify the desired communication outcome and should also include a method for measuring whether the objective has been achieved.

    2. Well-Defined Target Audience

    A key principle of DAGMAR is that the target audience must be clearly defined. For example, if the objective is to increase brand awareness, the advertiser must know exactly which group of consumers is being targeted.

    A reliable benchmark cannot be established unless the target market or audience segment is clearly specified.

    3. Benchmark and Degree of Change Sought

    Another important aspect of setting advertising objectives is establishing a benchmark measure. The benchmark indicates where the target audience stands at the beginning of the advertising campaign with respect to communication variables such as:

    • Awareness
    • Knowledge
    • Attitudes
    • Brand image
    • Understanding

    The advertiser can then determine the degree of change desired and measure the progress achieved during or after the campaign.

    4. Specified Time Period

    Every advertising objective should specify a time period within which the objective is expected to be achieved, such as six months or one year.

    The time period should be appropriate to the nature and complexity of the communication objective. Simple objectives, such as increasing brand awareness, may be achieved relatively quickly, whereas more complex objectives, such as repositioning a brand, may require considerably more time.

    5. Written Goal

    Finally, advertising objectives should be clearly written down. Written objectives help identify shortcomings, eliminate misunderstandings, and ensure that the objective contains all the essential elements of the DAGMAR approach.

    A clearly documented goal also makes it easier to evaluate whether the advertising campaign has achieved its intended results.

    Criticism of the DAGMAR Approach

    Although DAGMAR provides a systematic framework for setting and measuring advertising objectives, it has been criticized on several grounds.

    1. Problems with the Response Hierarchy

    DAGMAR assumes that consumers move through a sequence of stages—from awareness and comprehension to conviction and action. In reality, consumer behavior may not always follow this linear sequence. Consumers may purchase a product without passing through every stage in the expected order.

    2. Focus on Sales Objectives

    DAGMAR primarily focuses on communication objectives, such as awareness, comprehension, and attitude change, rather than directly on sales. However, advertisers and managers are often more interested in the actual sales and profits generated by advertising.

    3. Practicality and Costs

    Implementing DAGMAR can be time-consuming and expensive because it requires clearly defined objectives, benchmark measurements, research, and post-campaign evaluation. Smaller organizations may find such detailed measurement difficult or costly.

    4. Inhibition of Creativity

    The strong emphasis on specific, measurable objectives may sometimes restrict the creative freedom of advertising professionals. Excessive focus on measurable outcomes could discourage innovative or unconventional advertising ideas whose impact may be difficult to quantify immediately.

    Quick Summary of DAGMAR approach

    The DAGMAR approach provides a systematic method for setting, measuring, and evaluating advertising objectives. However, its assumptions about consumer response, emphasis on communication rather than sales, implementation costs, and potential restriction of creativity have led to criticism of the model.

    Hierarchy-of-Effects Model

    Among the various theories of advertising, the Hierarchy-of-Effects Model is one of the most widely recognized models. It explains the different stages through which advertising influences consumers and shows how advertising can gradually move consumers from awareness to purchase.

    The model can be represented in the form of a pyramid. At the lower levels, advertising objectives focus on creating awareness, knowledge, and comprehension. Once these objectives are achieved, subsequent objectives aim to move potential customers toward higher levels of the pyramid, such as liking, preference, conviction, and ultimately purchase.

    It is generally easier to accomplish advertising objectives at the base of the pyramid than those at the higher levels. As consumers move upward toward more action-oriented objectives, the number of prospective customers tends to decrease. Thus, while many consumers may become aware of a product, fewer may develop a preference for it, and an even smaller number may ultimately purchase and regularly use it.


    Stages of the Hierarchy-of-Effects Model

    1. Awareness

    If most members of the target audience are unaware of a product or brand, the communicator's first task is to create awareness. This may involve establishing basic brand or product-name recognition through simple messages and repeated exposure.

    However, merely capturing a consumer's attention does not necessarily mean that the consumer will notice, remember, or recognize the brand name. Therefore, advertising must be designed to make the brand clearly identifiable.

    2. Knowledge

    The target audience may be aware of the product but may not know much about it. Therefore, the next stage involves developing brand knowledge.

    Advertising should communicate information such as:

    • What are the brand's key benefits?
    • What specific appeals does the brand offer?
    • How is it different from competitors?
    • Who is the target market?
    • Why should consumers consider the brand?

    The objective is to provide sufficient information for consumers to develop a meaningful understanding of the brand.

    3. Liking

    Once consumers know about the product, the next question is: How do they feel about it?

    If the target audience has an unfavorable attitude toward the product, the communicator must identify the reasons for this negative perception. If the problem is related to the actual product, the company must first correct or improve the product before communicating its renewed quality or benefits through advertising.

    4. Preference

    Consumers may like a product but still prefer competing brands. At this stage, the communicator's objective is to build consumer preference for the brand.

    This can be achieved by emphasizing factors such as:

    • Quality
    • Value
    • Performance
    • Features
    • Benefits
    • Competitive advantages

    The aim is to make the brand more attractive than competing alternatives.

    5. Conviction

    A consumer may prefer a particular product but may still lack the confidence or conviction to purchase it.

    At this stage, the communicator's task is to strengthen the consumer's belief that the product is the right choice and encourage a strong intention to buy.

    6. Purchase

    Finally, some consumers may have developed both preference and conviction but may still postpone the actual purchase. They may want additional information, wait for a suitable opportunity, or simply plan to purchase at a later time.

    The communicator's task is to encourage these consumers to take the final step toward purchase. This can be achieved through techniques such as:

    • Offering a special price or discount
    • Providing a premium or promotional benefit
    • Offering product trials or samples
    • Providing additional information
    • Creating a sense of urgency

    Hierarchy of Consumer Response

    The complete sequence can be summarized as:

    Awareness → Knowledge → Liking → Preference → Conviction → Purchase

    The model therefore explains how advertising can gradually move consumers from knowing about a brand to developing positive attitudes and ultimately taking purchasing action.

     


    Post a Comment

    0 Comments